Pantry Envy: A Hometender’s Sin

October 11, 2022

This past weekend we visited family in Nebraska, including our niece and her husband. We had dinner in their lovely new home, and I have a confession. I had an extreme case of pantry envy. Kitchen envy, too.

Their pantry is the size of my kitchen. Need I say more?

And it was organized, spacious, and beautiful.

I was in love. Or should I say, IN ENVY.

Envy is not an unknown feeling for me. I am an enneagram FOUR and envy is the “sin” or “passion” of this personality type. In this case “sin” is not meant to be viewed as something bad or evil, but rather as the tendency to miss the mark in some way. When experiencing the sin or passion, we lose our center and are not our best selves.

Envy and the Enneagram

First a word about the enneagram.

The enneagram is an ancient system of self-understanding and self-discovery; a tool for personal transformation and development. Pronounced “ANY-a-gram,” the enneagram is a geometric figure that maps out nine fundamental personality types of human nature and their complex relationships.

My husband and I were introduced by a friend to the enneagram many years ago and studying it, returning to its subtleties and complexities over and over has been life-enhancing. The key step is to determine which of the nine personality types one is. After being introduced to the types, I knew almost immediately that I am a FOUR: an individualist or some times called the romantic or artist.

Envy is the sin or passion of the four.

Envy is based on the feeling that something is missing. Envy leads Fours to feel that others possess qualities that they lack. Fours long for what is absent but often fail to notice the many blessings in their lives.

The Wisdom of the Enneagram, The Complete Guide to Psychological and Spiritual Growth for the Nine Personality Types, by Don Richard Riso and Russ Hudson.

They see immediately who has more style, more class, more taste, more talent, more unusual ideas, more genius than they do. They see who is simpler, more natural, more normal, and ‘healthier’ than they are. There is nothing that a FOUR couldn’t be envious about.

The Enneagram, A Christian Perspective by Richard Rohr and Andreas Ebert

Noticing Envy

Envy has been an issue in my life, for sure. And while I am not able to say it has disappeared nor have I conquered the green-eyed monster, but I am more apt to recognize it quickly and ask, “What is this about and why am I feeling this now?” Plus, I am more able to turn the feeling into gratitude for my own blessings and to honor the gifts in someone else’s life.

So here’s how my pantry envy evolved.

What happened first was genuine delight for my niece. She and her husband had waited a long time for their dream house, and they had worked hard to make it happen. Bravo to them. In addition, how fun it was to see my niece’s hometending skills, her creativity, ingenuity, and her love of beauty, and I hope I expressed my appreciation for her gifts.

Then I sat with what I was experiencing within myself. Here’s what I uncovered:

I am living in what is sure to be my last house. I assume wherever I live next I will have a kitchen, but chances are it will be smaller and simpler, more basic than what I have now. This is because I am in my mid 70’s and closer to the end of my life than the beginning. I have had many kitchens –some bigger, some smaller–than my current kitchen and I have cooked and entertained no matter the size or the design, but I realize I no longer do that on the scale I once did. I feel some sadness about that. I know it is time to let go of some of that need. How grateful I am for all the times we have gathered family and friends around our table. How grateful I am for the ability to feed others and ourselves and to never lack for food in our home.

My envy opened me just a bit more to what I still store in my inner pantry, and that is a good thing.

By the way, my current pantry, which is a closet a couple steps down from the kitchen, is adequate. More than adequate for my current needs, and I need to remember that. It could use a bit tidying, however. I will put that on my list.

An Invitation

What moments of envy do you experience and how can they be a teacher? I would love to know.


If you are interested in the enneagram, I highly recommend the Riso and Hudson book I quoted. Also, you can take a test at OR

6 thoughts on “Pantry Envy: A Hometender’s Sin

  1. Thanks for your insights on envy. The children’s sermon for next Sunday will be about jealousy and envy. You’ve helped inspire my lesson. As for pantries, I don’t have any. I do use a corner, behind the door of our office. to store extras of a few things. Otherwise, it goes in my kitchen cabinets. I keep a very small amount of foodstuffs on hand for that reason, which is probably a good thing. No big freezer in the garage, either. Just the small one on top of the fridge.


  2. I have pantry envy from seeing your niece’s pantry, too! I have a large eat-in kitchen, but it’s the only dining and food storage space we have. We don’t have a separate dining room nor a pantry. We store all our extra food items, dry goods, and kitchen appliances and serving pieces in the basement.

    I have taken the Enneagram test several times online (various places) and come up with a different answer each time. So I thought I’d try the test links you posted, but you have to pay for both of them. I didn’t know that until the end of the tests, so I didn’t proceed. I find the Enneagram test frustrating, in general anyway. The questions to me are too general and I found I don’t even relate to a lot of them. I much prefer the Myer-Briggs personality test. I’m an INFJ, if you’re familiar with it.


  3. Sorry the enneagram is a frustration for you. There are free tests out there, too, but I think taking a class and having someone be a guide is a better way to determine your number. I am familiar with Myer-Briggs, too, but like the enneagram for its complexities –and its spiritual perspective. All that being said, the important thing is to be open to new understandings about ourselves.


  4. I enjoyed your honest assessment of yourself. I took enneagram tests years ago as well as the Myer-Briggs assessments. I don’t really remember the outcome. I have the results in a file somewhere. I wonder if they would be different now. I am also in my 70’s. I find this a wonderful time of life. I have received so many blessings and those make reflection an enjoyable pastime. My husband and I do that on quiet evenings. During the day I’m busy making more memories. I love your thoughtful blog posts, they make me think.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s